Il Pomodoro Wilhelmsplatz S-Mitte

2 Zohaib Jabbar - a year ago

I had such high expectations from this place but it failed to meet it.

We live right by there and always see many people dining here. We decided to come here for our anniversary.

We got tomato soup, minestrone soup, pizza Margherita and seafood pasta.

Tomato soup - 2 out of 5. The taste was on the sweeter side. Wish it had a little more taste.

Minestrone soup - 3 out of 5. The taste was okay, the vegetables were still on the harder side. We've had much better in the area

Pizza Margherita- 2 out of 5. I had SO much hope for this and was excited for it but when it came out it wasn't cooked fully, was still doughy and the tomato sauce was tasteless.

Seafood pasta - 2 out of 5. The seafood pasta is majority clams and mussels (for those wondering) with a few pieces of shrimp. There wasn't much taste and the pasta was still on the harder side.

Conclusion - We REALLY had high hopes but it failed us. We MAY try them again because they have woodfire pizza but there are other places in the area we'd much rather go to for Italian.

3 Selina Toh - a month ago

ok food, ordered the carbonara because it was recommended to me by a friend, it was ok, not amazing, not bad, just a little too rich for me to finish on my own.

friend ordered the aglio olio which the noodles were sitting on a pile of oil, way to oily to finish.

would recommend skipping both if you’re there and try something else.

4 Laura S. - 4 years ago

Went there for dinner on Saturday. It was pretty good. First star for getting a reservation even though I called less than an hour before we (party of 5) wanted to come in. Second star for giving us a heads up that pizzas will take about an hour due to so many pizza orders. Not great to have to wait that long, but when being told ahead of time I think it’s totally fine. Third star for vet friendly staff. Fourth star for great location (outdoor seating, cozy indoor seating).
Unfortunately no fifth star, because the food was only mediocre. The bruschetta were soggy and the tomatoes didn’t have a good taste. The pizza was good, but way too much oregano. So overall great visit, but not perfect.

5 Róbert Farkas - 2 months ago

Friendly service, the best frutti di mare, recommended

5 Ahmed Mestiri - 2 years ago

One of the best Italian food I have ever tried. The pizza is amazing and the taliatelle is very delicious. The atmosphere is very cool. The personal is very friendly and welcoming. The only thing is the waiting line to get a place. So I would recommend everyone to reserve a table before going there. But even if you wait, it was worth it. I would recommend the restaurant.

5 Kim Jezek - 4 weeks ago

We had a great dining experience here at IL Pomodoro. There wasn't a kids menu, but you could ask for smaller portions. The pizza was delicious as was the pumpkin special offered that night we visited. Of course, we saved room for dessert and shared delicious tiramisu, cannoli (one of they largest I've seen around town), and a berry frozen dessert served in a parfait dish. Clean restrooms upstairs. Extensive wine list.

Update: Today wasn't as good as in previous visits. We sat at our table for almost 10 minutes before someone came over to ask our order. I ordered the spicy shrimp dish and they were all severely overcooked. I had to wait for a long time for my dinner to arrive and couldn't finish it because it was so off-putting. The woman's bathroom was a mess and looked as if no one checked on it all night. We were really excited to come here and bring an out of town guest. Needless to say, they were not impressed.

5 Vin de Wildt - 4 months ago

Perfect restaurant for a pizza or pasta-diner. Staff is really friendly. And the food and prices are really nice. I would come back someday